Should Democrats Be More Like Republicans?

Marc Ambinder on The Week and Michael Tomasky on The New York Review of Books consider the question.

In the latest New York Review of Books, Michael Tomasky offers an answer that has a real ring of truth to it: Republican voters think about politics differently. They see politics as an enduring contest, not a series of discrete events. They are more apt to see the big picture, and therefore are easier to motivate.

Republican voters, being older and somewhat wealthier and more likely to own property, are more apt to see politics as a continuing conflict of interests that roll over from one election to the next — they can always be convinced that some undeserving person is coming to take away what they've earned.

Well, Democrats can teach their voters to think more like Republican voters in off-year elections. Tomasky describes a "massive and very well-funded public education campaign" that would basically drill into the heads of everyone who votes Democratic during presidential years that "they can't just elect a president and just sit back and expect that he or she can wave a wand and make change happen."

But how? What's the magic formula of words and threats that somehow makes this real for Democratic voters?

Maybe the party is too broad for a single perfect message to exist. Or maybe it will take casual language like Tomasky's, a bunch more losses, and actual pain that is easily attributed to Republicans before these drop-off Democrats will understand that they need to view the Republicans like the Republicans view the Democrats: as an enemy.

For good-government, consensus, let's-get-along, politics-can-be-pure types, this is a horrible message. Can it be true that the only way for Democrats to vote their true strength is to treat the opposing party just as poorly as the opposing party treats the Democrats? Can it be true that the only way to break the logjam is to embrace a politics that is even more loathsome, more unctuous and more uncivil than it is today? Maybe, yes.